Your Team Has Great Ideas. Your Reactions Might Be Killing Them.

Businesspeople sitting In a meeting and rolling their eyes while their colleague gives a presentation

Image credit: AndreyPopov

If you've spent any time in organizational life, you've probably sat through some version of this meeting. A leader looks around the table and says, "I want to hear your ideas. Nothing's off the table. Let's get creative." Someone takes them at their word and offers a suggestion that's a little unusual, and before they've even finished the sentence, the leader is explaining why it won't work. Budget. Timing. Compliance. "We tried something like that a few years ago." The meeting moves on.

In fairness to that leader, they probably don't think anything went wrong. They were being realistic. They were saving everyone from wasting time on an idea with obvious problems. But the person who spoke up learned something in that moment too, and it wasn't what the leader intended to teach. They learned that ideas in this room need to show up fully formed, pre-approved, and bulletproof, which is a pretty high bar for anything that's actually new.

I talked about exactly this pattern with Caroline Brookfield on a recent episode of my podcast, Yes, And with Avish Parashar (listen to the full episode here). Caroline is a speaker, trainer, and author of The Reluctant Creative, and she works with organizations on creativity, adaptability, and what she calls tolerance of ambiguity. She's also a veterinarian, which is not a combination you run into every day, and which turns out to be relevant here.

"I Want All Your Creative Solutions"

Caroline described something she sees all the time. A manager tells their team, "I want all your creative solutions." But if you ask the people who report to that manager, they'll tell you they bring creative solutions constantly, and they get shot down every time. Caroline called it a leadership bias the leader isn't aware of (I call it “your big yes, but”). These managers genuinely believe they want ideas. They want people to share them. They just don't notice the reactions they're having when the ideas actually arrive.

Caroline admitted she's been on the other side of this herself. Early in her veterinary career, pet owners would sometimes come in describing things they were doing with their animals that she didn't agree with. Her instinct was to react strongly and lay out all the reasons they were wrong. As she pointed out, that's not very effective if you actually want people to change. (Very few people have ever been lectured into changing their minds, and I say that as someone who gets paid to talk at people for an hour.)

What helped was an idea she picked up from another speaker about pausing. When someone says something and you feel that reaction bubbling up, the one where you just want to launch, you take a breath and say, "Tell me more about that." It's a small move, but it does two things at once. It makes you curious, and it interrupts the emotional reaction before it turns into a speech.

Caroline also shared an interesting idea from researcher Jennifer Mueller: when you have an immediate, strong reaction to something, positive or negative, it can be a sign that you might be experiencing bias. It’s not proof or a guarantee of bias. More like a little flag suggesting it might be worth checking your thinking before you trust it. For a leader hearing an unfamiliar idea, that's handy to know, because a strong, instant "no" can feel a lot like experience and good judgment, even when part of it is just discomfort with something new.

“Yes, And” Doesn't Mean You Have to Agree

When Caroline talked about "Tell me more," I immediately connected it to the difference between “Yes, And” and “Yes, But.” If you're not an improv person, “Yes, And” is the foundational principle of improv: You accept what your scene partner offers, and you build on it. In the business world, our default tends to be “Yes, But.” Someone suggests something, and we say, "Yeah, but..." and launch straight into the problems.

A lot of people resist “Yes, And” for a reasonable-sounding reason. They say, "I can't say yes to that. I don't agree with it." And I get it. If saying “Yes, And” meant you had to approve every idea anyone brought to you, it would be terrible leadership advice. You'd be implementing every half-baked suggestion that came out of a Tuesday afternoon meeting.

But that's not what it means. As I said to Caroline, you're not agreeing with the person. You're acknowledging what they said and learning more, instead of immediately launching into your counterpoints. "Yes, and tell me more." "Yes, and why do you feel that way?" The yes isn't to the idea itself. It's to the fact that someone offered an idea, and that it deserves to be understood before it gets judged.

This is a big part of the D in my YES AND framework, which stands for Dig Deeper. Most of us form an opinion about an idea within a few seconds of hearing it, and then spend the rest of the conversation defending that opinion. Digging deeper means slowing down long enough to understand what's actually being proposed, why the person proposed it, and what problem they're trying to solve. Sometimes you dig and discover the idea really is unworkable. That's fine. Now you can say no with a much better reason, yet the person who suggested it knows you actually heard them.

What “Yes, But” Teaches People

The tricky part for leaders is that most “Yes, But” reactions are well-intentioned. Leaders are often promoted because they're good at spotting problems, and organizations absolutely need critical thinking. Ideas should be evaluated, and plenty of them should be rejected. The issue isn't judgment. It's timing. When judgment shows up before understanding, the idea never gets a fair look.

And people notice. Most employees don't stop sharing ideas after one shutdown. It happens gradually. They start editing their suggestions before they make them. They shave off the unusual parts so the idea sounds safer. Eventually, many of them decide it isn't worth the effort and stay quiet, which leaves the leader wondering why nobody on the team ever seems to have any ideas.

Caroline touched on this kind of self-filtering in another part of our conversation, describing how we tend to judge our ideas at the same moment we're coming up with them, so they get filtered before anyone else ever hears them. I see this constantly in my own programs. When I talk about creativity, I have the audience play an improv game, and most people pause, think, and wonder, "Can I say that?" When they finally just open their mouths and start talking, they're usually laughing by the end and amazed at how much better they did than they expected. (I like to tell them they've just learned a very advanced improv comedy principle called "open your mouth and start talking.") The ideas were in there all along. People just learned to clamp down on them.

If a silly improv game with zero consequences can make smart people hesitate, imagine what a few years of Yes, But meetings will do.

Try This the Next Time an Idea Makes You Wince

The goal isn't to stop having reactions. You're going to have them. Some ideas will sound unrealistic, expensive, or just plain weird. The goal is to stop letting that first reaction make the decision for you.

The next time someone suggests something that triggers an immediate objection, try this:

  • Notice the reaction. Pay attention to that "launch" feeling Caroline described. The stronger it is, the more useful it is to slow down.
  • Hold off on the explanation. You can always tell them why it won't work later. That option isn't going anywhere.
  • Ask a genuinely curious question. Not a gotcha question disguised as curiosity. A real one.
  • Explore the thinking behind the idea. Even an unworkable suggestion often points at a real problem worth solving.
  • Then evaluate it on its merits. Now you're judging the idea, not your first impression of it.

A few questions that work well:

  • "Tell me more about that."
  • "What made you think of that approach?"
  • "What problem would that solve?"
  • "What would need to be true for that to work?"

Caroline made another point worth borrowing: Curiosity isn't only for other people's ideas. It's also for your own reactions. A leader who stops and asks, "Why do I keep saying no to all these ideas?" is doing the same work, just pointed inward.

And to be clear, curiosity is not a promise. Asking "Tell me more" doesn't commit you to implementing anything. It commits you to understanding the idea before you decide what to do with it.

The Ideas Are Already There

Almost every organization says it wants people to think creatively, share ideas, and take initiative. But the number of ideas a team brings forward depends a lot on what happened to the last few. If those ideas were met with an instant “Yes, But,” people learn to bring fewer ideas, safer ideas, or no ideas at all, no matter how many times the leader says they want creative solutions.

Near the end of our conversation, I told Caroline that if people walked away with just one thing, I'd want it to be this: When you have a strong reaction, get curious first. I still think that might be one of the most practical leadership habits there is. You don't have to agree with an idea to give it a chance to be heard, understood, and explored.


P.S. If your leaders say they want more ideas from their teams but keep getting silence or safe, small suggestions, that's exactly the kind of challenge I help organizations work through. My keynotes and interactive training programs give managers and teams a chance to actually practice catching their automatic “Yes, But” reactions and replacing them with curiosity and “Yes, And” thinking. If that sounds like something your people could use, let's talk.

P.P.S. Caroline and I covered a lot more ground than I could fit here, including her DANCE framework for creativity, why daydreaming deserves a spot on your calendar (or at least away from your phone), and her inner critic, Todd, who apparently likes lollipops. Give the full episode a listen here.

Avish Parashar

About the author

Avish Parashar is a keynote speaker, author of Say "Yes, And!" to Change, and host of the Yes, And podcast. For more than 20 years he's used improv to help leaders and teams handle change. His big idea: the biggest obstacle to change usually isn't resistance. It's apathy.


Recent Posts


{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Contact Avish Now to Learn How He Can Help Make Your Next Event a Success!

>