Say “Yes, And!” to Creativity and Uncertainty with Caroline Brookfield

What if creativity isn't just about coming up with great ideas, but is actually one of the best ways to become more adaptable, handle uncertainty, and navigate change?

In this episode, I'm joined by Dr. Caroline Brookfield; veterinarian, keynote speaker, and author of The Reluctant Creative: 5 Effortless Habits to Expand Your Comfort Zone.

Caroline believes we're all creative, even if we don't think of ourselves that way. And she makes a compelling case that practicing creativity can help us become more comfortable with ambiguity, make better decisions, and approach change with greater confidence.

We talk about why fear of judgment holds so many people back, how to deal with your inner critic (Caroline has actually named hers Todd!), and why giving your brain permission to wander might be more productive than constantly trying to stay busy.

We also explore Caroline's DANCE framework, five practical habits anyone can use to become more creative, curious, and adaptable.

As an improviser, I found a lot of connections between Caroline's ideas and my own "Yes, And!" philosophy. And I especially loved our discussion about how curiosity can help us move past knee-jerk reactions and become better problem solvers, leaders, and collaborators.

If you've ever thought, "I'm just not a creative person," or found yourself struggling with uncertainty and change, this episode is for you.

Key Takeaways

  • Everyone is creative. Creativity isn't limited to art or performance. It's a fundamental part of solving problems and navigating everyday life.
  • Creativity builds adaptability. Practicing creativity in low-stakes situations can help you become more comfortable with uncertainty when the stakes are higher.
  • Fear of judgment is normal, but it doesn't have to stop you. Learn how Caroline handles her inner critic by giving it a name rather than fighting it.
  • Daydreaming has real value. Creating space for your mind to wander can help you discover connections and solutions you might otherwise miss.
  • Novelty fuels new ideas. Trying unfamiliar things gives your brain more experiences to draw upon when solving problems.
  • Curiosity can interrupt judgment. Instead of immediately reacting to an idea you disagree with, try asking, "Tell me more about that."
  • Create first, edit later. Separating idea generation from evaluation can unlock more creative possibilities.
  • Small steps matter. You don't have to transform your life overnight to build a more creative and adaptable mindset.

Relevant Links

Unedited Transcript

AvishHello, Caroline, and welcome to the podcast. How are you?

Caroline BrookfieldI'm good, thank you, Avish.

AvishExcellent. Well, I'm happy to have you here. I read your book, and there was some great stuff in there. And as someone who has some level of insecurity, I really appreciated that it reinforced some of the things I already believed, but also gave me some new ideas. So to begin, just to give everyone an overview, could you give us the quick, like, one-minute, you know, who I am and what I do?

Caroline BrookfieldYeah. So I am a speaker, and I also do training, and I'm also a veterinarian. I'm kind of a multi-passionate person. And my topic revolves around adaptability and how creativity and tolerance of ambiguity can work together to help you solve problems and lean into change and uncertainty with a better mindset.

AvishSo obviously I'm very biased, but you know, you've got a combination of adaptability, creativity, and uncertainty, which are all things I talk about because you just basically summed up to me what improv comedy is. But, and I know you've done stand-up, but have you, because I don't recall in your book reading about whether you actually did any improv comedy or not.

Caroline BrookfieldSo this will mean something to you, but not to most people in the world. I did a training on improv with Keith Johnstone.

AvishOh my. Directly?

Caroline BrookfieldYeah. He's Canadian. So he came to Calgary. I think he's since passed. He came to Calgary in, it must have been like 2000, 2001, and did a workshop. And so, yeah, I've done, I've not only done improv, but I've learned from the master.

AvishYeah. So for people who maybe aren't improv nerds, there's like two or three sort of grand wizards of improv, and it's like Spolin, Johnstone, and, you know, maybe like Del Close. And there's others I've probably flipped out.

AvishWell, it's funny then, you know, this is not about me, but just kind of a quick, you know, I'm basically self-taught when it comes to improv. I did it in college, and we had a director one year, and then he graduated, and I ended up being director from that point. I started my own group, so I didn't go through Second City.

AvishBut what I would do is I would read. This predates YouTube, right? So I couldn't like, I would read, and then I'd go to my rehearsal workshop and say, here's a principle I learned from a book, let's try it and see how it works. And I read the books, and then in the bookstore I found Improv for Storytellers, which was Johnstone's like a second book, not improv.

AvishAnd I, like, I was so all in on that book, and that just absolutely changed my, so to hear that you actually worked directly with him, I'm like, oh, I'm jealous. That's.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, it was incredible.

AvishFantastic.

Caroline BrookfieldI don't think I really appreciated it because I wasn't like you. I wasn't in the improv world. I'd always loved performance, which is kind of how I came to speaking.

Caroline BrookfieldI'd always loved performance, and in high school I thought maybe I should be in performance, but I didn't want to live in a basement apartment all my life, and I did not have the talent to, you know, act full-time. So I kind of, that's kind of where I decided to continue being a vet. But I always loved this performance aspect.

Caroline BrookfieldI joined a little improv group, very part-time, you know, I did some acting classes, but I don't think, like, I didn't even realize how much of, like, what it was to work with him until after the fact.

AvishYeah, it's funny how that works out sometimes. You go, you do something, it's like, oh, he's an instructor, he's really good at improv, and then later on you find out, oh, he's like considered one of the best.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, yeah. Yeah, exactly.

AvishWell, let's talk a little bit about, you just mentioned there about being a vet. So, you know, we're going to talk mostly about your speaking, your training, your book. But I'm curious, kind of, you know, most vets don't then go off and write books on leadership, creativity, adaptability. So sort of how did, how and when did that come about?

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, so kind of what I said about the high school thing, like, I was that three-year-old girl that was like, I'm going to be a vet, I love animals, you know, like, and a lot of people kind of go away from that. But I always loved that. I loved the science, and I really liked the academic part of it, the problem solving, which kind of ties back to creativity. And then I just, but I really loved performance. And so, like I said, I was like, I don't want to, you know, I don't think that's for me.

Caroline BrookfieldSo I went in to be a vet, and that, you know, took all of my energy, of course, to develop that and start working. But like, over the course of my career, I was like, I kept getting drawn back to it, whether it was acting classes or the improv. And then I got a job with Nestlé Purina, and one of my, like, 80% of my job was speaking, educating vets on nutritional management of diseases like gastrointestinal disease, like diarrhea, basically. And I loved it. I loved speaking, I loved educating, I loved training, I loved teaching. I was also a sessional instructor at the vet school here for a while.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd then I was like, well, it can't be that. I don't know if you ever read the book, like, there's a few, one of them is The Big Leap and Playing Big. And it's that thing like, well, a speaker, like, why would I be, like, and I'm like, you know, other people are speakers. Like, if other people can be a speaker, why can't I be a speaker? And then it kind of went on this deep dive into, like, what should I speak about?

Caroline BrookfieldBecause strategically, while I'm not, you know, to me, money is not my driver, but I was like, if I speak to vets, there's really not that many vets, and there's really not that many conferences. It's not really a sustainable business. So then I was like, well, who would I talk to and what would I talk about? And it always came back to things people asked me about, which was like, you know, I took a year and a half off to go backpacking around Asia and Australia, a rock climb, you know, I do stand-up, improv.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so it was all about taking these steps into uncertainty and just going like, what's the worst thing that can happen and just trying stuff. And so, as you know, as a creative process, it was a bit of a messy development into finding out about creativity. Because really, creativity is problem solving, and I'm a really good problem solver. And so what is that about?

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so then it's kind of, I leaned into tolerance of ambiguity and how creativity impacts it. So it's really about how to adapt by taking steps forward and, you know, mitigating the risk, identifying what's the risk, what's the worst that could happen, and then just having that confidence to just step off the edge of the pool into the deep end, you know?

AvishMm-hmm. No, I love that and the whole idea of just sort of taking the time to figure out what you want to do.

AvishAnd like, I mean, it's in my book I talk about, like I took YASAN and turned it into an acronym, right, and a framework. And so one of the. Explore and express your core, because it's like, who really are you?

AvishAnd I think in this society, we don't really, most people don't take the time to think through that. It's just like, well, what's the next thing I'm supposed to do? And then they don't, that's when you wake up 20 years down the road, like, whoa, what happened to life?

Caroline BrookfieldDo you know who, there's a quote, I don't remember who said it, it might be like Gary Vee or somebody, but it was, we underestimate what we can do in a year, but overestimate what we can do in a day or something like that.

AvishYes. Yeah, I forget who. I've heard that from a few different people. I don't know who originally. Yeah, it's like, we overestimate what we can get done in a day and underestimate what we can do in a year.

Caroline BrookfieldRight.

AvishSo it's.

Caroline BrookfieldLike you say, we wake up 20 years later, like, you know.

AvishYeah, which, jumping to the end of your book, because again, this ties into one of the things I think, I think, you know, you give this great framework and how to get all these things people can do. And then at the end, you say, take it one step at a time, right? Just like, don't, and that's the exact quote you're saying is like, yeah, we might look at this dance acronym, which we'll get to, and say, well, I mean, I'm going to do all these things, and we overestimate it, but if you just do little steps at a time, like, it's amazing how far you can get in a year.

AvishDo you feel that's sort of like been your progress, like with all these different multi-faceted things you've done, it's just sort of like, well, that's just, like, when you start and you, you know, if you do all that stuff, I assume you're sort of ADD like me.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, totally ADD. Diagnosed, treated, medicated, yep.

AvishDo you like think it through and be like, all right, well, now I want to do stand-up, so let me kind of plot out what I'm going to do for the next six months? Or you're like, well, I want to do stand-up, let me just go try, let me take a class or.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, yeah, that's exactly, like just jump in. Because I think for me, if I think about it too much, and that's the blessing and the curse of having, you know, the ADHD or ADD is, you know, you can just jump. And I think that's one of the benefits to it, but sometimes I don't think it through well enough, right?

Caroline BrookfieldSo the planning, you know, being on to the next thing, next shiny thing, you know, with, you know, with the tolerance of ambiguity, one of the dimensions is managing the uncertainty. And I'm very high in tolerance of ambiguity, which I'm assuming you are as well. And that is people who, you know, are willing to step into that place of unknowing. But there's a dimension that was identified in some research that's managing the uncertainty.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so I'm kind of going on a tangent here, I hope you don't mind, but the idea is that I'm really good at doing those things. I'm not so good at sharing other people how they can come with me. So that's one of my struggles.

Caroline BrookfieldSo I'll just jump in and people are like, wait, what are you doing? I don't know if you, that's relatable.

AvishWell, sorry, I was going to lead to the next question. This is something you talk about before you kind of get in your framework in the book. It resonated with me, as I briefly sort of jokingly mentioned, about being a little insecure is, you know, one of the things that prevents people from exploring their creativity or going into ambiguity is this fear of judgment.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah.

AvishAnd sometimes I feel like the following the bright shiny object, like it's done really well for me, right? I have an engineering degree and worked in computers.

AvishI did, I started and ran improv group years. I got a third degree black belt in karate. I got a speaking business.

AvishLike, but then I, you know, but there's a judgment of like, you know, I've been working on a novel for a long time. And it's like, it's another thing, but then you have people like, you start to worry about the judgment of like, oh, are people going to look at me like you can't stay focused on one thing?

AvishAnd so I'm curious how, whether it's internal, external, how does kind of judgment sort of factor into your philosophy around ambiguity, innovation, creativity, and adaptability?

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, it's huge. I mean, you know, I've thought, I don't know how many thousands of people I've asked in my keynotes, what holds you back from your creativity? And fear of judgment is like top, right?

Caroline BrookfieldSo, I mean, it's evolutionary, right? Because if we, when we kind of evolved to be a community species, we had to fit in. And if we didn't, we died. So, you know, we have this, this drive to be accepted and fit in. And we actually, we feel judgment like physical pain.

Caroline BrookfieldSo what I tell people is don't feel bad if you are worried about what other people think, because that is normal. That is a human biological response to wanting to survive. So how, but the good news is, since that time, we've also developed this massive frontal cortex, most of us. And, and we have that ability to think consciously.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd I think that's the difference, what I see with people who are able to take risks and step out and share their voice to do something different, to do karate or improv or stand-up or whatever it is, is that metacognition. You know, there was the Olympian, I forget her name, is it Evelyn? And she said, she has this quote I love. She talks about like thinking about her thinking. She's always thinking about her thinking.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so it's like, you know, when I go on, do stand-up, I'm doing it tonight. I haven't done it for like a year. I don't even have my set list prepared. But what's the worst that's going to happen? Some drunk 20-year-olds going to be like, she sucked. You know?

AvishYeah.

Caroline BrookfieldWhat's the worst that's going to happen? But it doesn't feel like that. It feels like I'm going to die. But I might die on stage, but I know that I can say to myself that, you know, nothing really bad is going to happen to me if people think my jokes about menopause are bad or whatever, right?

AvishSo that's one technique to deal with the inner judgment. And I know you've got a few others. Can you share like one or two others that you use to like help people?

Caroline BrookfieldYeah. Well, I had this technique that actually I spoke to some nurses and a mental health nurse said, oh, that's like internal family systems. I never heard of that. So I have an internal critic and name him Todd. I don't know why.

Caroline BrookfieldTodd, I think of this beefy, you know, security guard type guy. And he's there to keep me safe. And so when I'm going to speak to groups or on stage, he's like, don't, what if they think you're lousy or what if they think, you know, you're a terrible person or, you know, whatever.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so I imagine giving Todd a lollipop because he likes lollipops. And I'm like, hey, Todd, I know you're trying to keep me safe. You know, I love you for that. I need you at times, but right now, why don't you just go eat your lollipop? And, you know, if I need you, I'll call you.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so that's almost a physical representation of me putting that inner critic kind of aside. I'm not like big on like, I hate my inner critic. Like it's nothing like that. You know, Todd's my buddy. He's trying to keep me safe, but sometimes I need, I've got the, maybe I have the frontal cortex bigger than him. And I'm like, you know, I don't think I need you right now.

Caroline BrookfieldSo is that kind of what you were thinking?

AvishYeah, yeah. And I think it's such an interesting approach. It makes logical sense once you think it through and you know how like therapy and emotions work.

AvishBut I think for a long time, even still probably to this day, I still get mad at my inner critic and like. Then it makes me feel worse about myself that I allow myself to feel bad about my inner critic.

AvishAnd I think this approach of naming it and just like acknowledging it, but not like fighting and being like, oh, yeah, I get you. Like I understand why you're there. It just like relieves the pressure of it. So I'm definitely trying.

Caroline BrookfieldWhat about you? Do you have something? I mean, you obviously perform. So what do you do?

AvishYeah, I don't have a good strategy. I have more of a, I have more of a grit your teeth and say, you know, screw it, I'm going to go do it.

AvishYou know, and it's, it's funny. It's not really an issue for performing, keynoting, all that stuff. It's more the other stuff in my life.

AvishYou know, like for me, I've said oftentimes like I'm a bit of an introvert and shy. So like networking events are like the bane of my existence. Going to like a cocktail after a walking room, people you don't know, you have to like introduce like, so that's an area where I usually just don't do anything effective.

AvishI just kind of hang out long enough to show my face and then slip out when no one's looking.

Caroline BrookfieldIs it the networking or is it the superficial crap?

AvishIt's, it's the, it's, it's terrible. It's the first 10 seconds. It's the, it's the interrupting people.

AvishLike once I'm in a conversation, like if someone comes up to me and chats, I'm great. Once we're talking, it's great. But that like super hard judgment of like, are you bothering them? Do they want to talk to you?

AvishYou know, they're here to meet people from the industry and you're the speaker, right? And a lot of people be like, you're the speaker, of course I want to talk to you. And I'm like, oh no, they're here to network with their friends or their industry contacts. Like I have nothing to offer them. It's like that judgment.

Caroline BrookfieldThat self-reflection of like what's, yeah.

Caroline BrookfieldYou know, it's funny. I mean, I'm going to go on another tangent here, but you know, the research that I follow, especially for tolerance of ambiguity, I think a lot of people don't know how many dimensions there are. Like there's like nine dimensions.

Caroline BrookfieldSo like for some people, maybe yourself included, and I'm not saying that this is it, but one of them is social ambiguity. So you might be like, you know, I jump into things, I do stand-up or improv, like whatever, I go on stage, but when I walk into a room of people I don't know, and that could be like, you know, that specific dimension of tolerance of ambiguity is like me with managing the uncertainty with leading people along with me.

Caroline BrookfieldLike maybe that's one dimension. So, because it's funny, because there's so many people I meet that are like, oh, I'm super high in ambiguity. I can, you know, I'm like, I'll do anything, whatever.

Caroline BrookfieldBut then they say something similar like you just did. And it's like, that's interesting. Like maybe, you know, that's where you exhibit less tolerance of ambiguity possibly.

AvishNo, that is interesting. I never heard about the nine dimensions, which is, because I do think too often, even as speakers, we paint with too broad a stroke. And it's like, you're the creative or you're not. You know, you're either social or you're not.

AvishBut it's like, no, it's like nuances and levels. And well, let's get into that then, because this is, well, before we get into the ambiguity, which is the second step, let's just talk about creativity.

AvishObviously, I'm biased. And of course, I was agreeing with everything here. But you believe that all people are creative, yes?

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, I mean, it's science. We are all creative, right? It depends on how you define creativity. That's what I find is the barrier. People are still often thinking creativity has to be something artistic or something recognized. But as humans, it's part of what makes us human is our creativity.

AvishYeah, and I talk about this when I do my creativity programs, the same thing you talk about, which is, you know, kids, like incredibly creative, right? I mean, you had studies in there about like what, 98%?

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, 98% of kindergartners scored as genius creative on this. And it's not a published study, which makes me mad, but Dr. George Land and his team, they were supposedly writing a creativity test for NASA. And then they gave it to kindergartners. And 98% of them scored as genius creative on this test.

AvishAnd it's, you know, again, my YesAnd framework, like one of the letters is like A is access and apply your creativity. So I'm all on board with this.

AvishBut there are a couple of things you mentioned there I wanted to touch upon. One thing I think you do a better job than I did is talking about like why creativity, right? I talk about it more in general, like it's ideas. And my book is very focused on change.

AvishBut you've got a whole like laundry list of like here's where creativity can be of benefit. So what are some of the key ones that maybe listeners of this podcast may not even think about when they think about creativity? Like here's how it's going to be.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, yeah, it's my nerd alert, like going into the research. I think, so one of the main things that I think people don't know, and they probably know it intuitively, but creativity makes you happier. I mean, that is in ample, ample studies. You do something creative and you're happy.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd a Connor study from not that long ago, it was like the next day. So some of these studies are a bit problematic because they're journal-based and self-reflection-based. So, but there are ample studies to show that if we use our creativity and things like knitting, making a meal, you know, planting a garden, those are the creative things I'm talking about. It makes us happier. That's broadly one thing.

Caroline BrookfieldThe other broad thing that I think is something people don't know, and it really is a thinker, creativity makes you more tolerant to ambiguity. That's kind of how I discovered tolerance of ambiguity. Because if you think about it, anything you do that's creative, if you're painting, you don't know what your painting's actually going to look like until it's done.

Caroline BrookfieldIf you're trying a new spice in your dish, you don't know what it actually is going to taste like until you try. Or like my husband who substituted orange juice and soup for five alive. Not good. But you don't know. He didn't know. He's like, maybe it'll taste good. Did not.

AvishSo wait, I'm not sure. Maybe it's a Canadian thing. What is five alive?

Caroline BrookfieldOh, gosh. Like Sunny D.

AvishOkay, yeah. Like an orange.

Caroline BrookfieldLike a sweet flavored kind of syrup. You don't have five alive in the U.S.? Oh, weird. Okay.

AvishMaybe not in Philadelphia. I don't know.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah. That's so funny. Yeah, things that you just don't know because they're part of your world. But yeah, it's like a really sweet kind of like, not carbonated, but it's like a sweet kind of drink.

AvishYeah, yeah.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, so it was not good in soup. So, but the idea that when you're doing something that you're creating is like taking an idea in your head and putting it into the world. That's kind of my broad definition of creativity. It's really stepping off that space of knowing what's going to happen and not knowing.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so if you do that in a space that's low stakes, then when you go to stand in front of people to do improv or speak or share an idea in a meeting, you're like, my body's done this before. Like I know this feeling. I interviewed this violin player, like a maestro, and he called it taking off the guardrails when he improvised. And so as an improviser, you know how that feels. Like there's no structure, there's no support, and it's very unsettling for people.

Caroline BrookfieldSo creativity is actually a tool to help you lean into uncertainty and change. Like, and it's researched. It makes sense. Not everything that makes sense is true, but it is also true with research. So those are the two things that I think people need to know about creativity.

Caroline BrookfieldBut also, it's problem solving. You know, like all creativity is solving a problem. Like how can I make this soup taste bad? Or how can I, how can I make people laugh? Or how can I advance our Q4 goals to meet our targets? Like that's all problem solving, and it's all creativity.

Caroline BrookfieldSo I kind of went on a rambling there because.

AvishNo, no, it's great. And that kind of leads into the, that made me think of a question I want to ask, but I think it leads directly into the dance framework. So, and I apologize at the top.

AvishI don't think I mentioned your book. So I mentioned you have a book, but so I read your book. It's called The Reluctant Creative Five: Effortless Habits to Expand Your Comfort Zone. And those five steps, just like I said, I got YesAnd as an acronym.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, I love it.

AvishYou took the word dance, and that is an acronym. So just, you know, we're not going to talk super at length, right? People should go get the book and read the book. But I just want to go through what the five steps are and maybe give people a takeaway or two kind of what they can start doing with it. But I'm transitioning this right now because, you know, the D stands for daydream.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah.

AvishSo when you talked about, you were talking about creativity and ambiguity and whatnot, it made me think about kind of being in that space of boredom. And that kind of goes right into the D and the dance framework. So before I go into that, could you explain the D for people kind of how daydreaming relates to all the stuff you talk about?

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, so daydreaming, I've pitched it many times as a standalone talk, and no one has ever taken me up on it. But it is, but if anybody does, it's executives. They're like, actually, I do need to make more space for that. So daydreaming is just mind wandering. And to clarify, mind wandering is not always healthy because it can lead into rumination and things like that.

AvishI wanted to ask you about the difference between those two.

Caroline BrookfieldOkay, yeah, yeah. So mind wandering is important because of our default mode network. You know, if there's any nerds listening, or I know you're obviously a nerd, you're an engineer. So I say that in the nicest way possible.

AvishGuilty as charged.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah. So the default mode network is a system in the brain that they didn't actually know existed. They kind of found it by accident. And it's when you're mind wandering, it's different areas of the brain that connect and talk that they didn't actually even know connected before this. And it started when they did this study, and they were doing two conditions. And you know how like when you're doing a taste test, you take like a cracker to like cleanse your palate or whatever. So they were like, well, we need a condition in between that's a control, which is like, you know, baseline.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so they told the participants in this study with functional MRI machines to think about nothing. And the researcher who did the study didn't even actually recognize that it was someone else reviewing the data like years later. That's like, wait, why is all this stuff happening when they're thinking about nothing? Like the mind was extremely active.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd you know, if you've ever been in the shower or driving to work and an idea pops into your head or a solution, that's your default mode network. And the problem is it's working over time, but it feels like you're doing nothing. And so it's not, it's not like highly productive. It feels like a waste of time. But without that daydreaming time, we can't tap into this like associative thinking.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd as humans, one thing we do really, really well is emotional connection for associative thinking. It's almost like you're plugging your idea into this wall that's connected to like a whole network of ideas that seem completely unrelated on the surface, but might help you solve that problem. So I think that's, I don't know, kind of rambling again, but that's the idea behind it is that we need to give our brain space to daydream with the caveat to the, like I reject this idea that you need to be bored because I think the principle is true, but I think that, you know, boredom is really just telling you you need to take action, right?

Caroline BrookfieldSo the problem is that if people take that action into ruminating and like mental health issues, that it can end up, you know, becoming negative for our mental health if we ruminate. But we also need that time, like put down your phone, you know, stand in line and look at the people around you, you know, look at the sky. Don't like sit on your phone while you're eating breakfast. Like there's small, easy things you can do to give your brain that space to process.

AvishYeah, it's interesting because I've been talking about boredom a lot in a lot of my recent podcasts. I've been sort of actively trying to be more bored.

AvishBut the way you said about, you know, what I think maybe the refined way of saying it is like, it's not necessarily you need to be bored. It's that you need less stimulation.

AvishAnd I think, I think when we feel bored, we immediately in this day and age go for a quick dopamine hit from the phone, from the internet. Because, oh, this is why I realized my transition into asking about this was very awkward. It's because I'd forgotten exactly why I did it.

Caroline BrookfieldI'm with you.

AvishBut then I remembered. It's because you talked about how, you know, the studies show that when you are creative, it makes you happier.

Caroline BrookfieldYes.

AvishAnd I was saying that over this past like month now, I've really been focusing on less stimulation, like not checking my social media, which leads to a certain amount of boredom, which leads to more like time to daydream.

AvishBut my mood has been greatly improved. And you'll see studies about this, right? When people cut down on social media use, their mood improves.

AvishAnd I think you're not getting the dopamine hits, but it's also giving your mind that space to be creative.

Caroline Brookfield100%. Yeah, I agree.

AvishSo if someone wants to get started with the first step in your framework, like, like how do they, I mean, it's a weird sort of assignment, like go daydream. Like, so how do, do they pick a specific thing? Do they just let their mind wander wherever? Do they go for walks? How do you recommend people get started with the daydream step?

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, I mean, it's, to me, I'm not very good at like step, you know, people are like put it in your calendar and it'll get done. I don't know. I'm like, I don't feel like doing that calendar. Like, it doesn't work for me. So I'm better at like principles.

Caroline BrookfieldSo for this, the principle is if you have a moment to let your mind wander, do it over the phone, especially nowadays over the phone. Like it's just put your phone away. And whether that is, I do better with habit pairing than steps. So for me, it would be like, I don't ever bring my phone out. Like we are not allowed to have the phones at the dinner table.

Caroline BrookfieldI don't look at my phone for the most part. You know, I'm sure like I do it sometimes because we're human, but I try not to bring my phone out when I'm eating breakfast. I try to just like look out the window. We have a bird feeder. And just basically just put your phone away when you don't need it. And then just being more conscious of it, I think that would be the easiest first step.

Caroline BrookfieldBecause our minds wander 40 to 50% of the time. Our minds are wandering. It does happen whether we want it to or not. It's just how do we do that more intentionally? And more intentionally would be thinking about a problem you're trying to solve instead of like thinking like wandering, like, oh, I'm going to let my mind wander. And then your mind wanders to like that annoying thing your kid did or that email you got.

Caroline BrookfieldIt's like, what's the problem I'm trying to solve? And let your mind wander on that. And then another, another way to tap into it more effectively and, you know, intentionally is to think about it in a fantastical situation. So let's say you're working with a team and you're trying to implement some kind of new initiative, like an AI thing. Well, what would you do if like instead of AI, it was ants? Or what would you do if like there was only one person on your team? Or what if, what if it was all dogs?

Caroline BrookfieldLike, you know, just think about some really, like as improv, you know, like some random wacky idea because that takes you out of that curse of knowledge and helps you think about things in a way that doesn't focus your curse of knowledge or like your, because it's hard to be creative when you're an expert in your domain, right? So it's hard to think differently as I'm sure you would agree.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so thinking fantastically and mind wandering about something fantastical on a problem you're trying to solve is really a very effective way for those who are like, want to do it right, you know?

AvishYeah. No, I love it. I love it.

AvishAll right, well, let's go down to the A. And, you know, you've mentioned this, you've said this phrase, tolerance of ambiguity, a number of times, but we haven't really dug into what that means. And now in the framework or your acronym, how it relates to the things you talk about.

AvishSo let's talk about A, ambiguity, and also tolerance of ambiguity. Like what do you mean by that and how do people use it?

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, so I mean, I was so fascinated to read these studies about tolerance of ambiguity and this research specifically out of the Queensland University of Technology in Australia. And Adaptic Minds has developed this test. It's like a Myers-Briggs for ambiguity. And they have these nine dimensions of tolerance of ambiguity.

Caroline BrookfieldSo one of them, like we mentioned, was, so tolerance of ambiguity is really like how sphincter clenching is it for you when things go sideways, right? Like that's really what it is. And so that's kind of what I always thought of ambiguity. Like ambiguity is something in the world. It's like that green and gold dress where people are like, it's green and it's gold. Or like, is it coming at me or going away from me? Like that's ambiguous.

Caroline BrookfieldIf we see something and we can interpret it in a number of different ways, that thing is ambiguous. But it doesn't care about us. It doesn't care about being ambiguous. It's just a thing. When we see something that's ambiguous, we feel uncertain.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd kind of like that biological, we need to resolve that at all costs because at one point, if we were uncertain, we died. So we hate uncertainty, even if it's not a threat. Like it has to, ambiguity is perceived by us as a threat. And it makes us anxious. I mean, like you have that boss that's always yelling at everybody. If they bring you a slice of chocolate cake and they're like, come into my office and have some cake, like that's ambiguous. You're like, oh, that's a threat, right? It's a good thing.

Caroline BrookfieldSo, so with all the change, like you talk about this happening in the world, ambiguity and uncertainty is extremely stressful. And there's two things to it. We can try to resolve the ambiguity, which is really important in leadership because we need to resolve role ambiguity. It's the number one driver of burnout. So we need to remove ambiguity where we can. But where we can't remove the ambiguity, we need to build that tolerance so that we can be less stressed and move through change.

Caroline BrookfieldBecause when we face ambiguity and feel uncertain, there's studies behind this. I won't get into because I could talk for hours. But we research status quo solutions. Even if we see ambiguity and we don't consciously recognize it, there's studies to show that that makes us more resistant to other people's ideas and makes us more stuck in our own ideas and more resistant to change.

Caroline BrookfieldSo when do we need to be more adaptive in change? When we're faced with change, but it makes us retreat and do what we've always done. And we don't realize we're doing that. And so the way that the reason it interacts with creativity is that if we use our creativity or creativity helps us move through that ambiguity.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd with this research out of the University of Queensland, with these nine dimensions that we talked about with the social ambiguity, and one of them is desire for difficult, desire for challenging problems. One is managing the uncertainty, like all these different dimensions. The only thing that influences all nine dimensions is creativity.

Caroline BrookfieldSo there's like these eight habits of mind. They talk about specific actions you can take to help improve these different dimensions. But the only one that influences all of them is creativity. So if you want to be more tolerant of change, you want to be making clearer and more decisive decisions when you don't have all the information, or you want to freak out a little bit less when your plans go sideways, use your creativity.

AvishThat's great. Let's, I want to talk about the other three in the framework, but let's pause for a quick commercial because you mentioned this is really important for leaders. And we haven't yet really talked about kind of how you work with leaders and with the groups. So for people who are kind of vibing to this, they're like, oh, you know, this sounds great. Like how would you work with organizations and individuals?

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, that's really, thank you for asking. So I'm a keynote speaker. So I speak to associations and organizations who are looking for kind of a light delivery, but deep message about how a creative mindset can help you move through change and ambiguity and uncertainty with a happier mindset.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd then I also started offering what I, because what I was finding is these leaderships teams would be getting together and they were having the same circling back conversations that they were having at work and the same things we're talking about over Zoom. So I started offering these two-hour sessions where I come into a strategic planning retreat or, you know, an executive away day and do either creative problem solving strategies to help them think differently and work together as a team or work through some challenges on, I have another framework called the 3C method for moving through ambiguity.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so it's really about like how do you actually face that change and uncertainty and move through it? So they're just like little, you know, and of course I do many other workshops. I mean, people are like, do you do this? I'm like, I talk about creativity and ambiguity. Like I can, you know, whatever you need, let me build something for you.

Caroline BrookfieldBut those are the kind of two main kind of areas that I target as far as like what I, how I help people and, you know, just love talking. Obviously, I'm passionate about it. So I just love talking about it.

AvishOkay. Well, yeah. And then we'll have your website and everything in the show notes so people can link and find out more about you.

AvishAll right. So let's continue on then with the N, which is novelty. And, you know, you kind of start out talking about seeking novelty with intention.

AvishAnd I'm curious kind of why you added the with intention, how that's different from just, maybe it's like an AD thing, right? I'm always seeking novelty. Maybe seeking novelty with intention is more of what I need to do.

Caroline BrookfieldI don't know. Is that what I said? I don't remember. I'm not, I'm not.

AvishI think you said that. That's what I wrote down, but sometimes I can't read my own handwriting and sometimes.

Caroline BrookfieldNo, no, it's probably true. Yeah, I think maybe that, I don't know why I would have said that, but maybe it's about just finding ways to do new things, really. So maybe it's intentionally seeking novelty was maybe what I meant in that context.

Caroline BrookfieldBecause we tend to, especially as we get older, we just kind of know what works. We know what brand jeans fit us and we know what coffee we like. You know, we kind of get used to the same old, same old, but, you know, I use this analogy of, and it relates kind of to the daydreaming as the default mode network.

Caroline BrookfieldSo like I say, imagine you have a tiny billionaire that's your buddy. So what a tiny billionaire is like to do?

AvishOh, you're asking me.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, yeah. Sorry.

AvishI mean, they like to travel to new places and eat at like the best restaurants and buy cool things.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd they like to go to space, right?

AvishWell, yeah, that's true.

Caroline BrookfieldThey like to go to space. So imagine you have a tiny billionaire and you're trying to solve a problem and the tiny billionaire said, let me solve your problem. I'll take it to space with me. And so you give them the problem, they take off, but you don't know what they're doing because you've lost radio contact. So that's kind of the default mode network.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd what's happening is that little billionaire is traveling around the universe of your brain, trying to find experiences, connections, relationships, emotional events, and trying to solve that problem for you. So when they come back to Earth, it's like when you're in the car and you're like, poof, oh, there's an idea. That's your tiny billionaire coming back from the space of your brain with a solution.

Caroline BrookfieldThe number of stars and planets and meteors in your brain is proportional to how much novelty you seek, how many experiences you have. So if you do the same thing all the time, you don't travel. Like there's a study that shows the CEOs who worked abroad are more creative, right? So it's like the more experiences you have that are different than your baseline, the more ideas and data points your tiny billionaire has to solve that problem.

Caroline BrookfieldSo if you have very few satellites and asteroids in your brain, you kind of aren't going to come up with a really unique solution. But if you have a very expansive universe, because you're trying new things, you're reading about things that are outside your expertise or you're traveling or you're interested in meeting people from other cultures and how they do things. You know, those are all things that will help you be more creative and solve more problems.

AvishYeah. And I think it's, I talk a little about this too. And I think it's, you know, I recommend people do stuff outside of their area of expertise.

AvishIt's like, you know, I'm a computer engineer, so I'm going to read computer books and learn how to code better and all this. And like, that's great. And do that, but spend some time learning about other things because it is like the subconscious, the connections and stuff.

AvishAnd like I have this, like it's like I taught, especially over COVID, I taught like a virtual improv comedy class.

Caroline BrookfieldOh, cool.

AvishAnd literally an idea came to me about how to think about improv because I happened to be reading a random book I found that was about the, like history of calculus, like how calculus sort of developed. And it got me thinking. I brought it, I talked to people in this improv group about it. So it's like, it is amazing how, like what you're saying, like novelty, new things keep stimulating your mind because that just.

Caroline BrookfieldWell, it's that associative thinking, right? Like you read that book about calculus and you saw calculus in a way that applies to improv.

AvishYes.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd probably a way AI could never do, right? Because it's conceptual. Sometimes it's emotional. Like, you know, why does like, you know, bombing on stage and stand-up remind me of, I don't know, like getting laughed at in class when I was in grade two, right? Like it's emotion, these emotional connections and this associative thinking that we can leverage more as humans that makes us different.

AvishYeah. So it's really just about getting that input and stimulation. All right. I love that. So the C is what I'm a huge fan of because it's very yes Andy. I mean, they all sort of are yes Andy, but that's.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah.

AvishThat's the power and thing of the general broad brush of yes Andy. But so talk about, and I like you brought up this idea of curiosity in a way that I hadn't really heard about or read about, about diverse versus specific curiosity.

Caroline BrookfieldYes.

AvishWhich I thought was interesting. So if you could talk a little about curiosity in general and that kind of the difference between those two.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah. So curiosity is foundational for creativity because if you don't wonder how things could be different, you're never going to try and solve a problem, right? So if you're just like, well, this is the answer and you're not curious. And so curiosity is foundational for any change of creativity to how things can change.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd yeah, this diverse and specific is really interesting. And I'm glad you brought that up because I kind of forgot about it. I wrote it in the book and I went on like a, you know, ADHD hyperfocus on that. And I haven't talked about it lately. So thank you for bringing that up.

Caroline BrookfieldThe idea is that there's kind of different ways to be curious. And one way could be like, I wonder how things could be different because you're curious about all of the possibilities. The other one is more specific, which is less expansive. And that is like, I'm curious, how can I resolve this discomfort of not knowing?

Caroline BrookfieldLike your curiosity is driven more by resolving the discomfort than the expansiveness. So I guess that's kind of the difference. I don't know if that's where you're kind of going.

AvishYeah. No, I like that. And as you were talking, I realized that, I mean, curiosity is almost like the binding factor of the first three, right? It's like curiosity kind of ties to novelty.

AvishLike instead of seeing something new, be like, no, being like, oh, let me learn more about that. And ambiguity, instead of being like, I got to avoid the ambiguity, it's like, well, let me get curious about it.

AvishAnd obviously daydreaming is just let your mind wander around whatever you're curious about.

Caroline Brookfield100%. Yeah. I mean, I wish it could be first, but then it would be like CAD, CAD, I don't know how it would be.

AvishWell, you can make a candy, but with an E instead of a Y.

Caroline BrookfieldOh, yeah. There you go. That would be a lot of IP I'd have to change.

AvishYeah, yeah. No, I think the answer is great because then you tie that in with like the dancing with ambiguity and things like that. So it works great as is. So is curiosity and cultivating curiosity just a matter of people reminding themselves to be curious? Or is there any kind of like way that you recommend people add more curiosity to their life?

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, I think, well, something that specifically works for me, it may hopefully be relatable to you and to your listeners is as a veterinarian, you know, when I work in small animal practice, people sometimes bring some wacky ideas or some things they're doing with their pets that are like, okay, I don't know why you're doing that, right? And so what I found myself in the early of my career is I'd react strongly and give them all the reasons why they're wrong and how they could, you know, feel embarrassed about the stupid things that they're saying, right? Which is obviously not effective if I really want to, you know, for people to change.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd I remember listening, I wish I remember his name, but a speaker, he was a nutritionist, but he was talking about having a pause. And when people say something and you have a strong reaction to that, instead of allowing that, it's like a feeling. I don't know if you've had that feeling before Avish, where you're like, you have this feeling that like bubbles up that you just want to launch it. It's like just take a pause and take a breath and say, tell me more about that.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd it meets the curiosity thing, but it also turns off that like reactionary, that emotional reaction to whatever it is, the idea or the suggestion or the point of view that you're reacting to. Because what I find really fascinating, a book from Jennifer Mueller, she talks, she's a researcher, she talks about, so one of the things, again, a little aside, I'm fascinated with this idea between bias and intuition, right?

Caroline BrookfieldSo I'm like, what's the difference between a bias and what's the difference between that and intuition? Because really, how would you know the difference? If it's an unconscious bias, you call it intuition, you wouldn't know, right? And one of the things she taught, and she's the only person I've ever read that actually, you know, comes close to answering this question.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd she says, if you have an immediate strong positive or negative reaction to something, it's a little bit of an indicator that you might be experiencing bias. And so if we want to get away from this world where we're knee-jerk reacting and we're, you know, looking for evidence to support and confirm our existing belief, then that feels good. And outrage feels good.

AvishYeah.

Caroline BrookfieldSo to get back to curiosity, if we stop and pause in that moment of that like feeling of, huh, tell me more about that. I mean, not only would the world be a better place, but we would solve more problems.

AvishYeah. I agree 100%. This is one of the areas I talk about with yes And versus yes, but it's like, instead of your initial response to something you disagree with being yeah, but it's like yes And, tell me more. Yes And, why do you feel that way? And I love that.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, I love that reframe of that accepting and accepting adding on, right?

AvishYeah. And again, it's not even, not even really accepting because I think sometimes people don't want to say yes or yes And because I don't agree with them. It's like, well, no, you're not agreeing with them. You're just acknowledging and then learning more instead of immediately launching into your counterpoints, which I think is, I like that distinction.

AvishI hadn't really thought about that. It's like paying attention to your emotions so that strong emotion indicates there might be a bias there as opposed to just intuition, which I think is incredibly helpful, like as a way for people to just pay attention to themselves.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah. But you have to be willing to think about your thinking and be wrong, which is also a whole nother topic in itself.

AvishYeah, yeah.

Caroline BrookfieldI also come back to curiosity. Why do I think the way I do? Why do I have these reactions to these messages? Why do I, you know, why do I ask like the common thing is in a manager will be like, I want all your creative solutions.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd people, if you ask their people that report to them, they're like, yeah, I always give them creative solutions or her, and they always shoot them down. But then they say, I want creative solutions. And it's a bias. It's a leadership bias that they're not aware of.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so it would take a leader to look at themselves and say, why do I keep saying no to all these ideas? Because they think they want creative ideas. They think they want people to share them. They're just not even aware of the reactions they're having.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so I think that curiosity not only is for other people's point of view, but to yourself to be like, why do I react the way I do?

AvishYeah. I mean, I think you've shared a lot of interesting and valuable stuff here, but I think that one thing for me is probably the most, if people could just walk away from here and then when they have a strong reaction, first getting curious and saying, well, why am I having? I think that could absolutely be transformative for people at any level, you know, whatever area it is. So.

Caroline BrookfieldI agree. Yeah. You know what I mean? We'll save the, we'll change the world and save the world in a one-hour podcast or whatever.

AvishOne dance at a time, right? All right. Well, let's move to the final one, the E. Obviously as an improviser, I'm my bias.

Caroline BrookfieldYes.

AvishStrong agreement with this, but E stands for edit later.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah. It's a hard one. That was a hard one to put in a letter, but yeah. But you probably know this idea of divergent and convergent thinking, right? As an improv, like divergent is your go-to, right? Like thinking about all the possibilities. So edit later comes down to the foundational idea behind creative thinking, whether it's an improv or stand-up or, you know, thinking of a new product line for your drink manufacturing. New five alive, four alive, six alive, I don't know.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so divergent thinking is what most people think of when they think of creative problem solving. It's like, what are all the things we can do with this? How can we, how can we launch this product? What are all the ways we can do it? And then convergent thinking is also part of creative thinking. That's selecting. So in improv, when you do improv, it would be something like your brain's going to think of all the possibilities and then you're going to grab one. So there's convergent is always, there's one answer.

Caroline BrookfieldSo when I say like the difference is if you're writing a poem, a divergent question would be, what am I going to write my poem about? Like anything. But a convergent question would be, what word am I going to put at the end of this stanza or whatever I'm going to put to make this poem amazing? So the problem, and this goes back to Dr. George Land, who did that kindergartner research with the NASA test, he calls it the gas and the brake. So the gas is the divergent thinking. You can go anywhere you want, but the brake is also really, really important. But the problem is we do them both at the same time.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so as an improv, you've probably seen this with the people you coach and work with, like they think of something, but not that. So sometimes I'll do, you know, with the groups I work with, and I'll be like, how many of you were thinking of a weapon or how many of you were thinking of something not safe for work? Like we go to these ideas and not that it has to be that, but we filter our ideas before we even share them.

Caroline BrookfieldAnd so the editing later comes from a quote attributed to Hemingway, which is, "Write drunk, edit sober." So the idea is that when you're diverging, you're fully in divergent. No bad ideas. Say what you mean. Say what you want. Like no idea is off the table. And then when you're done with that, and then through the creative problem solving techniques or design thinking approaches, you can expand on those ideas.

Caroline BrookfieldBut at some point, you're going to need to select, right? So, and that's, but it should be done separately. So you don't do that while you're creating the ideas. You do it, okay, now we're done creating the ideas. Now we're going to converge. So that's also very fundamental to creativity because we have to allow, and it comes back to that idea of judgment and inner critic and not wanting to look bad, but also this habit we have of, you know, you and I are fortunate.

Caroline BrookfieldOur executive function is not as highly developed as some other people's, which allows us to think more creatively because we don't have that executive function like stopping us from thinking that way. Yeah.

AvishYeah. That's why I do the improv. When I'm talking about creativity, I do an improv game and I have the audience play it. And I'm like, you know, I just use a very advanced improv comedy principle there called open your mouth and start talking.

AvishBecause I'm like, most people will pause. Like you're pretending to be an expert on something. Most people will pause and think, and oh, can I say that? I'm like, whenever I just, and then I have people do it and they're amazed.

AvishIf they just start talking at the end, they're all laughing and they're like, wow, I did way better at that than I thought I would. And it's exactly what you're saying that it's like, once you get yourself to just create first and edit later, it's amazing how creative that point we talked about in the beginning, right? That all people are creative. It's in there.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah.

AvishWe just clamp it down.

Caroline BrookfieldYeah. Yeah, we don't allow it to come out and because we're worried about judgment for our bad ideas. And sometimes that's, I don't know if you've ever done this as well, but sometimes when you actually deliberately seek bad ideas, it actually helps because the pressure's off, right?

AvishYeah. I had a friend who's like a strategic consultant and he says a lot of his strategy sessions will ask people like, what's the dumbest thing we can do right now? Right? Because it just frees up and people start laughing and they don't judge. And yeah, it's a ton of fun.

AvishAll right. We are coming up to the end of our time. We've gone through the whole dance acronym. I'm going to finish up in just a moment by asking a final question.

AvishBefore I get to that, for people who want to learn more about you, maybe engage your services or just read more about you. I know you got a whole blog with a bunch of articles and things. You got your book. So where are the best ways for people to find and connect with you?

Caroline BrookfieldYeah, probably to read kind of more about my ideas is my website. It's just carolinebrookfield.com. And then I'm pretty active on LinkedIn. Send me a carrier pigeon. Get creative.

AvishThere you go. Get creative. I love it. All right, Caroline. I'm going to finish up with a question I pretty much end all my podcast episodes with is I talk about the difference between yes And and yes, but because I believe the world will be a better place. If everyone started with a default of yes And, what is one small thing that you believe if people did, it would make the world a better place?

Caroline BrookfieldWell, I think one small thing would be to get curious. I think that's really like it goes to your principle of yes And. Instead of reacting to the world and especially outrage, it feels so good. Try to defer that and get curious because that is a longer burn than just the short-term reaction.

AvishWell, I love it. I agree. And that is great. Caroline, thank you so much for chatting and sharing your wisdom and experience and expertise. We are going to link everything in the show notes. So everyone, please go check out Caroline's stuff. And yeah, be sure to subscribe and leave us a review and we'll see you back soon. Caroline, thank you so much. This was awesome. We'll have to have you back again at some point.

Caroline BrookfieldThank you. It flew by.

Avish Parashar

About the author

Avish Parashar is a keynote speaker, author of Say "Yes, And!" to Change, and host of the Yes, And podcast. For more than 20 years he's used improv to help leaders and teams handle change. His big idea: the biggest obstacle to change usually isn't resistance. It's apathy.


Recent Posts


{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Contact Avish Now to Learn How He Can Help Make Your Next Event a Success!

>